Introduction
Organizational culture is an important aspect of any business, as it shapes how employees behave and interact with each other, customers, and stakeholders. It refers to the shared values, beliefs, and assumptions that exist within a company, and it can influence everything from decision-making to productivity. To create a strong and positive organizational culture, leaders need to understand different organizational culture models and how they can be applied to their specific business needs. In this article, we will explore various organizational culture models, their characteristics, advantages, and disadvantages, and their impact on organizations.
Competing Values Framework
The Competing Values Framework (CVF) is a popular model used to assess and diagnose organizational culture. Developed by Robert E. Quinn and Kim S. Cameron, the CVF is based on the idea that there are four distinct types of organizational cultures, each with its own set of values and priorities.
The four types of cultures identified by the CVF are:
- Clan Culture: This culture is characterized by a family-like atmosphere where employees are encouraged to work collaboratively and support each other. Clan cultures value teamwork, participation, and employee development. Examples of companies with a clan culture include Zappos and Southwest Airlines.
- Adhocracy Culture: Adhocracy cultures are characterized by innovation, creativity, and risk-taking. These cultures value experimentation, flexibility, and adaptability. Examples of companies with an adhocracy culture include Google and Apple.
- Market Culture: Market cultures are characterized by competition, achievement, and results. These cultures value competitiveness, goal-setting, and a focus on the bottom line. Examples of companies with a market culture include Amazon and Coca-Cola.
- Hierarchy Culture: Hierarchy cultures are characterized by formal structures, rules, and procedures. These cultures value stability, predictability, and efficiency. Examples of companies with a hierarchy culture include IBM and McDonald’s.
Advantages: The CVF model provides a comprehensive framework for understanding and diagnosing organizational culture. It can help leaders identify the strengths and weaknesses of their current culture and develop strategies for improving it. The model is also flexible and can be adapted to different industries and organizational structures.
Disadvantages: The CVF model has been criticized for oversimplifying complex organizational dynamics. Some argue that it does not take into account the unique cultural factors that exist within different organizations. Additionally, some organizations may find it difficult to fit neatly into one of the four categories.
Organizational Culture Profile (OCP)
The Organizational Culture Profile (OCP) is another popular model used to assess and diagnose organizational culture. Developed by Robert A. Cooke and J. Clayton Lafferty, the OCP is based on the idea that there are seven key dimensions of organizational culture.
The seven dimensions of organizational culture identified by the OCP are:
- Innovation: The degree to which an organization values and rewards creativity, experimentation, and risk-taking.
- Attention to Detail: The degree to which an organization values precision, analysis, and attention to detail.
- Emphasis on Outcome: The degree to which an organization values results, achievement, and a focus on the bottom line.
- People Orientation: The degree to which an organization values and supports its employees.
- Team Orientation: The degree to which an organization values and encourages teamwork, collaboration, and participation.
- Aggressiveness: The degree to which an organization values and rewards competitiveness, assertiveness, and achievement.
- Stability: The degree to which an organization values and emphasizes stability, predictability, and maintenance of the status quo.
Advantages: The OCP model provides a detailed and nuanced approach to understanding organizational culture. It allows leaders to identify the specific dimensions of culture that are most relevant to their organization, and provides a framework for understanding how these dimensions interact with one another. This can be particularly valuable in situations where a leader is seeking to change or improve the culture of their organization, as it allows them to identify which dimensions are most in need of attention.
Disadvantages: However, the OCP model has also been criticized for being too complex and difficult to apply in practice. Some critics have argued that the model is overly theoretical and lacks practical guidance for how to use it to assess and manage organizational culture. Additionally, the model assumes that organizational culture is a static and unchanging entity, which may not always be the case in practice.
Schein’s Model of Organizational Culture
Edgar Schein is another prominent scholar in the field of organizational culture, and his model has been influential in shaping how scholars and practitioners think about and approach culture. Schein’s model is based on the idea that organizational culture is comprised of three levels: artifacts and behaviors, espoused values, and underlying assumptions.
Artifacts and behaviors refer to the visible and tangible elements of organizational culture, such as dress codes, office layout, and rituals. Espoused values refer to the values and beliefs that an organization publicly espouses, such as a commitment to customer service or innovation. Underlying assumptions are the unconscious, taken-for-granted beliefs and assumptions that underlie an organization’s culture, and are often difficult to identify or articulate.
Advantages: One of the key advantages of Schein’s model is its emphasis on the importance of underlying assumptions in shaping organizational culture. By recognizing that culture is not just a set of visible behaviors or stated values, but is also shaped by deeply ingrained assumptions and beliefs, the model provides a more nuanced understanding of how culture operates in practice.
Disadvantages: However, Schein’s model has also been criticized for being too abstract and difficult to apply in practice. Some critics have argued that the model’s focus on unconscious assumptions makes it difficult to identify and measure cultural dimensions in a meaningful way. Additionally, the model may be less useful for organizations that are primarily focused on tangible, measurable outcomes, rather than more intangible cultural elements.
Conclusion
Organizational culture is a complex and multifaceted concept that plays a critical role in shaping the success of organizations. By understanding the different models of organizational culture, leaders can gain a deeper insight into the values, beliefs, and practices that underpin their organizations. The competing values framework, the OCP model, and the cultural web are just a few of the many models available to help leaders analyze and assess their organizational cultures.
Each of these models has its strengths and limitations, and leaders should carefully consider which model best aligns with their organization’s needs and goals. Regardless of which model is chosen, it is important to approach organizational culture as a dynamic and evolving concept that requires ongoing attention and effort.
In today’s fast-paced and ever-changing business landscape, organizations must be agile and adaptable to succeed. By fostering a strong and positive organizational culture, leaders can create a sense of shared purpose and direction, inspire innovation and creativity, and build a high-performing team that is equipped to tackle the challenges of the future.
References
Abrahim, A., & Zewdie, S. (2020). Organizational Culture Assessment at Ethio-Telecom Using Competing Value Framework. European Journal of Business and Management Research, 5(6). https://doi.org/10.24018/ejbmr.2020.5.6.669
Maximini, D. (2014). Organizational Culture Models. Management for Professionals, 9–25. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-319-11827-7_2
Maximini, D. (2018). Organizational Culture Models. Management for professionals, 187–204. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-319-73842-0_18
Maximini, D. (2022). Changing Leadership. Springer eBooks, 53–62. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-031-15022-7_4